Katabasis by R. F. Kuang
My affliction is being bound to read every new book R. F. Kuang produces, only to figuratively dissect it and tear it to shreds. Is she brilliant? Overhyped? Academically magnificent, sure, but emotionally ignorant? I still haven’t worked it out, but I’m endlessly fascinated by this author’s mind, impressed and discomfited in equal measure.
Kuang’s latest novel, Katabasis, follows Cambridge ‘analytic magick’ students Alice and Peter on their journey to Hell in the hope of rescuing their terrible-but-brilliant deceased professor. While this dark academia fantasy suggests a high-stakes premise, with desperate PhD students floundering their way through Hell’s courts, unsure if they’ll ever make it out, there is less action than one might expect. The exciting and fantastical are replaced with long and clumsy explorations of philosophical and mathematical theory.
Kuang’s books garner reactions, and a reaction, either positive or negative, is what I want in a novel (and I’m sure a lot of publishers would agree). Was the concept of Katabasis interesting? Of course. Interesting and insane. I would pay to have heard the reactions to its elevator pitch had it come from the mouth of a lowly new writer. Did I mispronounce the title of this book and thus bestow all my friends with the incorrect pronunciation like an infectious disease? Naturally.
But did I finish this book? Actually, no. It lost me in parts, I grew bored, and I skipped ahead, promising myself I’d go back, but I never quite cared enough to. I found that the premise promised more than the finished product delivered, and the decidedly unlikeable characters wore on my nerves. But maybe that’s what makes it more interesting. Its promise felt unfulfilled, leaving me frustrated and wanting to complain about it to anyone who would listen.
And believe me, I talked about this book a lot. And here I am, doing it again. Kuang is like a nut I’ve yet to crack. Do you love her or hate her? Either way, you’ll have a reaction, a declaration I can make with the same certainty that I know I’ll read her next book just to tear it apart, too.
Karolina